Nik lives in Essex, UK and works in London as the editor of MacUser magazine. The posts and comments on this site do not necessarily reflect the views, opinions of values of his employers.
send an email // view profile
Cidade de Deus (City of God) is one of those films that has been on my ’should watch’ list for ages. It’s been sitting in my cupboard for about four months, always getting pushed aside when there was something else (usually something more trashy) taking priority. Anyhow, last night we sat down with a bottle of wine, slipped it into the DVD player and watched.
And I’m very glad we did.
Yes, it’s violent. Yes, it’s noisy. Yes, it’s in Portuguese. But it pulls you along at a terrific rate and the violence, tough and non-stop though it may be, does quickly become secondary to the plot as you follow the (true) story of the drug dealers living in a Rio de Janeiro slum called the Cidade de Deus.
It is many stories rolled into one, but primarily those of Knockout Ned’s corruption and transformation from a good looking straight-down-the-line kind of guy a to dead criminal, and of Rocket, the narrator, who grows up to be a photographer for the local paper and so escapes the slum.
The filming technique is almost as ingenious as the way they have wrapped the story around itself. It makes for very uncomfortable viewing, though, not least because of the police corruption. They appear to be as bad as the drug lords, and seemingly are easily bought off.
That is not nearly such painful viewing as the one scene I almost couldn’t watch, where the dealers had lined up two small, screaming kids against a wall, given a gun to another one and forced him to choose one or the other and shoot him dead. The camera seems to linger forever as he makes up his mind, and all the while you’re praying that it will just subtly pan away and save you from watching what might happen next. Fortunately it is obscured by someone’s head by the time the bullet is fired, but the joyous reaction from the infant school-aged killer is enough to turn your stomach.
I don’t think we said a single word from the moment it began until the end credits started to roll two and a bit hours later. We were captivated by a foreign film that was so not like the kind of thing we would ever choose to watch.
I can see precisely why it has been so highly praised. It is difficult viewing, but should be seen by all. The Empire critics chose it as their film of the year. IMDB readers rated it the 18th best film of all time.
Related posts:
- Volver
I went to see this one with an entirely open mind. Apart from the first two paragraphs of a review tacked up on the wall... - Working girl
Why is going back to work never painless? I arrived in the office this morning to find my computer dead. There was a power spike... - Bowing out
According to this story in the Guardian, Pierce Brosnan has quit the Bond films. Hmmm... if he has it's a bad thing, but then Roger...
2 Responses to “Cidade de Deus”
One of my favourite films of the last few years; it’s an absolute corker, especially when you take into account the fact that so many of the actors were in their first film.
I should really watch it again.
• Posted at 3:20 pm on August 17th, 2005 by Parky.Leave a Reply
It is still on my ’should watch’ list. But, from what you write, I figure I should take action, so it ends up in my ’should watch again’ list…
• Posted at 7:43 pm on August 16th, 2005 by Xarro.